Five Nights At Freddy's Oneshots - Yandere! Nightmare x Reader (2024)

Nightmare's P.O.V

I can't get her out of my head. I have to have her, I need her. I'll find a way, there has to be a way.

No matter what it takes

3rd person P.O.V

You were happily chatting with Nightmare Freddy, your best friend.

"-And then he just bolted!"

Freddy laughed, you giggling along with him. While unknown to you, a jealous Nightmare lurked in the shadows.

'He's not allowed to make her laugh!' He cried in his mind.

His fists clenched and unclenched, his nostrils flared, his eyes burned with fury.

"Are you okay?" Asked a voice.

Nightmare looked to where the voice was heard. Not seeing anything, he looked down.

Plushtrap sat on the ground, looking up at him with childlike innocence.

Nightmare smirked.

"I can use you."

TIMESKIP

He grinned at the tied-up (human) Plushtrap. Writhing and crying, staring at the serrated blade Nightmare held, bruises already beginning to show on his pale flesh.

"Shut up brat, I'll be back,"

Nightmare growled, setting down the blade so Plushtrap could see it clearly, reminding him of the punishment that was sure to come if he screamed.

Nightmare turned, sending one last evil glare at the terrified child, who shrunk even more. Then turning to the door, and slipping out.

Meanwhile...

You were running around the house frantically,with the equally concerned Freddy following. The two of you were looking for Plushtrap, as he seemed to have gone missing.

"Plushtrap!?"

You called out worriedly. You loved the little rabbit as a younger brother, you certainly didn't want anything happening to him.

"(Y/N)?"

You looked behind you. Spotting Nightmare, you had to force a smile due to the current situation. After all, it would be unfair to treat him badly, as he was always so sweet and kind to you.

"Yeah?" You asked.

"I think I know where Plushtrap is. Just follow me."

ANOTHER TIMESKIP

After Nightmare managed to persuade Freddy not to come with you, which was a bit odd, he lead you to where Plushtrap allegedly was.

The two of you reached a door, one of which you rarely ever opened. Yet he opened the door politely.

"Ladies first,"

You smiled at the prospect of seeing your little Plushtrap. Even if Nightmare's smile unnerved you.

When you entered, it was completely black. You couldn't see much, the only light being the artificial light just barely spilling in through the open door. Even then it was only a sliver.

Then you heard a deafening slam.

You spun around, trying to spot Nightmare in the darkness. Which proved impossible.

Then the lights flickered on, revealing a smirking Nightmare.

"Nightmare what the he-?!" You screamed, only for him tocover your mouth.

He was still smirking , but now with the absence of your loud breathing, you were able to hear whimpering from behind you.

Your eyes widened, tearing yourself away from Nightmare, and whipping around.

Plushtrap sat on a chair, tied and gagged. His flesh decorated with multicolored bruises, each large and ugly.

Your eyes filled with tears at the sight, hands moving to cover your mouth.

"He'll be even worse if you don't stay here with me."

Nightmare's voice rang out from behind you, sad*stic pleasure heard easily.

"W-why?" You choked out.

He moved closer, so close that you could feel his breath on your neck.

"Because, my dear, I love you. So much that I would KILL for you."

He mumbled, wrapping his arms around you and giggling.

You sighed, sadly. "W-well, do you.. Do you promise not to hurt anyone else?" You asked.

"I promise."

"Then, I'll stay."

MONTHS LATER

You sat in the corner of an empty room, holding your knees to your chest. You felt an incredible sadness inside, but no tears made their way down your face. You shed so many tears it seemed impossible to cry any more.

You knew the others were looking for you, yet they would never find you. He hid you, away from everyone else so he could so selfishly have you to himself.

You heard a door open, yet you didn't move from your position.

"Hello, my love."

You only grunted in response. He sighed, you hearing his footsteps nearing you.

He pressed a forced kiss on your lips.

"I love you," he whispers, nuzzling your neck.

You sighed, knowing you had no choice. You knew not to fight back.

"I love you too."

Nightmare Freddy: Why would you do that to Plushtrap?!
Nightmare: I didn't! Blame the author!
Joy: I'm not great with Yanderes. It was the easiest way to go.
Plushtrap: That's so rude! -Steals top hat-
Joy: Ugh! You little menace! -Chases Plushtrap-
Nightmare Bonnie: Why does she love that hat so much?
Freddy: It's basically her boyfriend to her. Ha, she's such a loner.
Nightmare Foxy: I knew you were a dick, but I didn't know you were THAT much of a dick.

Requested by DiamondsAndGold